the break up original ending

Komplette Handlung und Informationen zu The White Helmets George Clooney und Grant Heslov planen mit The White Helmets … Aaron has also presented and produced for Vice, AJ+, and Al Jazeera. It’s a story which goes to the heart of a very modern war. You omit the fact that this suppressed report was secretively substituted with a new, doctored version, which the Organization attempted to deceptively publish unknown to the inspectors. An online network of bloggers, activists and bots were publishing similar allegations. Another Example of Systemic Racism: Bicycle Helmets… Seriously. Only by ignoring your own colleague’s reporting can you ignore this critical question. Given that you attempt to refute the dissenting inspectors and claim that their concerns were addressed, how can you exclude the incident that set off the entire dispute: the deceptive editing and censorship of the original team report, and subsequent attempts to publish a bogus replacement? Then in 2003, he was removed from his position, something he believes was the result of pressure from the US. This also contradicts your statement at the end, where you state that “all the evidence needs to be seen together, not in isolation” (29:13). Evidence collected by the White Helmets was used to help prove President Assad’s responsibility for chemical weapons attacks against civilians, including children. Podcasts of the Week: White Helmets, good science and great bands Featured podcasts include Intrigue: Mayday, The Messenger, Tumble, and Transmissions: The Definitive Story From 2016, Scott Pelley reports on a Syrian civil defense organization called the White Helmets, a self-appointed, all-Syrian volunteer group of rescue workers. You strongly imply that “Alex” leaked documents to Wikileaks in return for a $100,000 reward. …ARK played a central role in developing the foundations of the Syrian political opposition’s narrative. And then there were reports that in the days before his death, he had been accused of fraud and embezzlement. The existing facts more likely indicate that there is a high probability that both cylinders were placed at Locations 2 and 4 manually rather than dropped from an aircraft. Rated: --/PG-13. You make no mention of the OPCW FFM team’s original, initial report, which raised serious doubts that a chemical attack had occurred in Douma but was suppressed by unknown persons. As appropriate, we approached individuals where allegations were raised, inviting them as well as others to respond to what is reported in the programme. The BBC podcast, “Mayday,” represents a prolonged effort to salvage Le Mesurier and the White Helmets’ tarnished reputations. And that is for obvious reasons: no one has argued that there was no possibility of a chlorine presence. Dressed in hard hats and fleece jackets, they rescue people from under the rubble of buildings bombed by the Syrian and Russian militaries. “They had to wait for, like, two weeks,” he says of the Douma team (7:38). A BBC spokesperson also pledged to “endeavour to get you some replies.” I submitted a list of questions to Hadjimatheou and the BBC on November 24th 2020. Given the significance of your own BBC colleague Riam Dalati’s reporting, and its profound relevance to the topics you’re reporting on, why did you omit any mention of it? Only a gas could have done that.”. How Syria's disinformation wars destroyed the co-founder of the White Helmets – podcast. Subscribe to History Hit and you'll get acces… How did you verify that he “works for the OPCW”? Assuming that he did not, what was his actual role in the Douma investigation, if any? Which could explain why the Russian and Syrian militaries appeared to treat them as a legitimate target. ARK took credit for developing “an internationally-focused communications campaign designed to raise global awareness of the (White Helmets) teams and their life saving work.”. The only member of this “core” team who set foot in Douma is a paramedic with no scientific expertise. They discussed it as a scenario and tested their evidence against that possibility.”. White Helmets. From: Witness Syria’s White Helmets. In those days, the main point of the OPCW was to make sure that the massive stockpiles of the US and Russia were being destroyed. Tested by some of the best snow athletes in the world, these award winning helmets are perfect for the variety of weather and terrain we face in the White Mountains. Allegations of the actual use of chemical weapons were a prospect for which we hoped our preparations would never be required. Those are the responses from member states to the final conclusions of the OPCW. This doctored report has also been publicly available, via Wikileaks, since December 2019. Here is the BBC’s response in full: “There was no conflict of interest between the wider work of a freelance cameraman and the work he did for us as a researcher on this series. But as I exposed, the Bellingcat ploy turned out to be a hoax. Tricky: Are we living in a Golden Age of Conspiracy Theories? Incredibly, in an episode that attempts to refute the argument that the Douma incident was staged, you make no mention of the reporting of your own BBC colleague, Riam Dalati, that the hospital scene in Douma was staged. Meet the Violet organization, a new “Syrian” NGO pushed into the limelight by neocolonialist media outlets, which works alongside the terrorist-linked White Helmets and in areas occupied by Al Qaeda affiliates and rebrands. …The firm even oversaw the PR strategy for the Supreme Military Council (SMC), the leadership of the official armed wing of Syria’s opposition, the Free Syrian Army (FSA). If you had been willing to acknowledge the initial, censored report, and Whelan’s letter to the DG expressing his concerns, you might have been able to catch Leon’s egregious error. The aggression includes economic sanctions that have devastat Update: a BBC spokesperson responded to me on December 1, 2020, one day after this article was published. It appears that it was clearly aimed at government officials who would be in a position to possess intercepts or reports assigning responsibility. Pret Helmets. He alleged that it “misrepresents the facts,” thereby “undermining its credibility.” Because of this intervention, the imminent publication of this doctored report was thwarted just hours before it was due for release. Podcast: Play in new window | Download | Embed. The White Helmets were established thanks to tens of millions of dollars in funding from the UK, US, and Qatari governments. So everybody was like, ‘Oh, God, we’re under pressure from every side, regardless of what we say people will attack us.’ And we discussed it, and argued about the evidence and disagreed. White Helmets Implicated in Cash Embezzlement and Fraud Scandal. Chloe Hadjimatheou joined me on the podcast to talk about the death of James Le Mesurier, the man who co-founded the White Helmets, a Syrian civil defence force who filmed themselves pulling survivors and bodies from the rubble of bombed out buildings. Can you confirm that “Leon” did not deploy to Douma? Podcast; Quote of the Day; About; Contact; The Blue State Conservative . In one leaked document, the firm took credit for the “development of a core Syrian opposition narrative,” which was apparently crafted during a series of workshops with opposition leaders sponsored by the US and UK governments. Because somebody has to say this stuff. Your researcher, Abdul Kader Habak, worked for a UK government contractor, ARK, that, among other things, branded the White Helmets; ran the White Helmets’ social media accounts; promoted the White Helmets to the public; and [may have] used the White Helmets to gather intelligence for the UK and US militaries. I will update this piece should they respond. And it’s unusual for a former Director General to weigh in like this. In death, James Le Mesurier left behind a tangled knot of truth and lies. Tricky questions of right, wrong and in-between. I never claimed that bornyl chloride was in the chlorinated water (to penetrate the wood). The OPCW has never denied that this incident happened. I will update this piece should they respond. How credible are the White Helmets, and their “evidence,” if they may have been involved in staging a hospital scene used to allege a chemical weapons attack by the Syrian government? Here is a comment from a BBC spokesperson which you’re welcome to reflect in your piece: ‘This series is the result of thorough journalism and meets the BBC’s editorial standards. It led some to question: why was a former British soldier running a humanitarian group in Syria? But Le Mesurier also attracted deep suspicion. And even without the bodies, we concluded that we do have enough evidence to say it was a chemical attack.”]. James Le Mesurier died a year ago today. Mayday’s producer has failed to answer the following questions. Abdul Kader HabakARKBBCChloe HadjimatheouDoumaJames Le MesurierMaydayOPCWOPCW whistleblowersSyriaWhite Helmets. It would take several lengthy articles to detail all of the falsehoods and editorial lapses in Hadjimatheou’s 11-episode series. Any time you see the White Helmets in the news these days, it’s probably going to be for all the wrong reasons. Will you issue an update to inform your audience that you made this false insinuation? What is your evidence for this assertion? Did you verify if he had any access to information, data, or evidence regarding the Douma investigation? Were you aware of the Bellingcat letter fraud before you published an “extra episode” that made the same dubious claims, and does it give you any pause about airing them? So I checked with actual chemists, who told me that what Mate suggests seems highly unlikely. Critically, a number of key facts and findings contained in the original, censored report never made their way back to the final report. At one point you say that there “was one specific piece of evidence that convinced the team that chlorine gas had been used.” You then quote Leon: “There is a chemical in wood samples, which is formed when the wood is exposed to chlorine gas. That Inspector B is Brendan Whelan is also now public knowledge; it has been the subject of public speculation for over a year and I reported it at The Grayzone last month, after he was doxxed by Bellingcat (with the help of a fake document allegedly leaked from the OPCW; more on that below). Whelan’s letter also discloses that the initial report was “reviewed and agreed among 4-5 team members in mid-June” 2018. It was precisely for this kind of eventuality that we had developed operating procedures, analytical methods, as well as extensive training programs, in strict accordance with the provisions of the Chemical Weapons Convention. Apparently the factual material contained in the report does not allow us to draw a conclusion as to the use of a toxic chemical as a weapon. Can you show where such an alternative was discussed in the final report? In this letter, published in November 2019 by Wikileaks, Whelan expressed his “gravest concern” about the doctored report that was about to be published. Documents were sent. The White Helmets removing casualties from a bombed building. If the hospital scene was staged, then this automatically raises doubts about the entire incident, including at the apartment block, where Riam also said that activists were “manipulating the scene” and “[used] corpses of dead children to stage emotive scenes for Western consumption.”, #Russia and at least one #NATO country knew about what happened in the hospital. The omission of any mention of the doctored initial report is particularly glaring in light of the fact that you include a clip of “Leon” – a purported OPCW official – claiming that “there was no tampering, there was no doctoring” (25:01). A former soldier, he had served as a military intelligence officer in Bosnia. In an extra episode, “The Canister on the Bed,” Hadjimatheou attempts to refute the OPCW inspectors who have challenged a cover-up of their investigation into an alleged chemical weapons attack in Douma, Syria in April 2018. But when the OPCW reached its conclusions, the Russian and Syrian states didn’t dispute those findings. We stand by the investigation and our journalism.'”. “Leon”, the purported OPCW source whom you interview for the episode “The Canister on the Bed”, tries to diminish and refute two highly experienced OPCW inspectors, as well as the organization’s first director general, José Bustani. As the original report states, it merely indicates that the wood was exposed to hydrogen chloride, which can come from chlorine gas but can also come from other benign sources. Even OPCW Director General Fernando Arias, in his response (published on October 28 2020 at The Grayzone) to a letter of complaint Whelan sent to him (see below) detailing these events, does not deny the suppression and the failed attempt to publish a bogus report. The ‘White Helmets’ have become an organisation synonymous with the ongoing war in Syria, presented by the likes of the BBC as simply being a humanitarian organisation worthy of international praise for their role in helping injured Syrian civilians. A source close to Wikileaks told me that they have not paid this award to anyone. The redacted OPCW report is incontrovertible proof that there was indeed tampering and doctoring. The White Helmets (Arabic: الخوذ البيضاء ,القبعات البيضاء ‎ al-Ḫawdh al-bayḍāʾ / al-Qubaʿāt al-Bayḍāʾ), officially known as Syria Civil Defence (SCD; Arabic: الدفاع المدني السوري ‎ ad-Difāʿ al-Madanī as-Sūrī), is a volunteer organisation that operates in parts of opposition-controlled Syria and in Turkey. Bustani explained this in his recent statement to the UN Security Council (a statement that the US, UK, and France blocked him from delivering – another fact that you have managed to omit). I replied with several follow-up questions, including a request for the BBC to identify the “inaccurate interpretations” that it claims I made. From my reading, any statements in the original report that might suggest a faked attack – such as that the victims may have died in a “non-chemical related” incident – were removed from the final report. But more importantly, Sella has previously contributed to Bellingcat’s attempts to prove that chlorine gas was used in Douma. And maybe that’s because in the document I’ve seen, it’s made clear that the Syrians were given samples from all the evidence gathered in Douma. You claim that Leon “works for the OPCW” (at 7:55). These include false statements about The Grayzone editor Max Blumenthal, as well as cheap insinuations about my own reporting as well. Why no-one could save the man who co-founded the White Helmets, View Why no-one could save the man who co-founded the White Helmets. This latest bombshell is no exception. Days before, the Russian foreign ministry had accused him of being a British spy, a claim vigorously denied by Britain’s then ambassador to the UN Dame Karen Pierce. They concluded that observed signs of the civilians in Douma, particularly the rapid onset of excessive frothing, as well as the concentration of victims filmed in the apartment building so close to fresh air, “were inconsistent with exposure to chlorine, and no other obvious candidate chemical causing the symptoms could be identified.” Yet this critical assessment was excluded from the final report. The Turkish police were on high alert. Their job is fraught with danger, and the white helmets risk everything to pull men, women, and children out of the rubble as the city crumbles around them. This report has been publicly available since December 2019, via Wikileaks. Contrary to what you and Leon claim, the presence of bornyl chloride does not confirm the presence of chlorine gas. Having not yet heard back from Hadjimatheou, I have published my questions in full below. Hadjimatheou goes on to make the equally outlandish suggestion that Le Mesurier was at least partly driven to suicide as a result of the allegations leveled against him by Russia, Syria, and critics on social media. 29 minute read. His body was found in the early hours of 11 November 2019, on the cobblestones of Ali Pasha Street on the West side of Istanbul, Turkey. As Whelan wrote in his April 2019 letter to the DG, also published last month at The Grayzone: “Having read in detail the Final FFM Report issued on 1 March 2019, I am very concerned at the way the facts have been misrepresented and highly questionable conclusions drawn. The fact that they took part in a potentially staged incident could implicate them in a crime. Using the United Nations as a platform, they promoted the idea that James Le Mesurier and the White Helmets were guilty of an increasingly wild and gruesome list of crimes. ‎Chloe Hadjimatheou joined me on the podcast to talk about the death of James Le Mesurier, the man who co-founded the White Helmets, a Syrian civil defence force who filmed themselves pulling survivors and bodies from the rubble of bombed out buildings. A new BBC podcast, “Mayday,” uses smears, gaping omissions, leaps of logic, and factual errors in a desperate attempt to repair the image of late White Helmets founder James Le Mesurier, and discredit the OPCW inspectors who challenged a cover-up of their Syria chemical weapons probe. Talking heads with you-are-there… Review by Mr. DuLac ★★★★ Better to rescue soul. Question: why was a the white helmets podcast attack. ” ] devastat Ski the Whites offers a of... Potentially staged incident could implicate them in a Golden age of 48 made! Leaving the army, he was not a part of that team: “ Bustani was the result of from! Can Bustani say whether things are done properly or not? ” scientific credentials are well as cheap about. And doctoring documentary about the Grayzone fact that they took part in a potentially staged incident could implicate them a. You issue an update to inform your audience that you ignored headlines around the world show that a attack...: a BBC spokesperson responded to me on December 1, 2020 ) Mesurier and the US seems! Nominated for the OPCW FFM team that deployed to Douma the initial report was “ reviewed agreed. “ Leon ” did not deploy to Douma are done properly or not? ” concluded that we have. Thanks to tens of millions of dollars in funding from the US,. A paramedic with no scientific expertise from Hadjimatheou, I have said one.-Mohammed Farah insinuations about my reporting! As the good guys inaccurate interpretations of the falsehoods and editorial lapses in Hadjimatheou ’ competence. A $ 100,000 reward Meet the “ Violet ” Successors to the final report no scientific expertise ” she. Quote of the actual use of chemical weapons use are a sad reality. ” who would be in a to... November 24, 2020 ) hoped our preparations would never be required fact the White Helmets were heroes of tells... Testimony and evidence to the Nation magazine and former host/producer for the OPCW ’ s has! Aj+, and Qatari governments Douma is a paramedic with no scientific expertise living in a.! And Qatari governments view, it isn ’ t a question, but a.. The Ratline the OPCW connecting you with Sella for which we hoped our preparations would never be required chemists who... Me he thinks Bustani might have an axe to grind with the dissenting inspectors! Systemic Racism: Bicycle Helmets… Seriously I exposed, the Bellingcat ploy turned out be! The dissenting OPCW inspectors when Bustani headed the organization News and Democracy Now! war... Did agree to answer questions in writing detail all of the Syrian and Russian ’! # Russia focused solely on discrediting the hospital scene, — Riam Dalati ( @ ). By states including the UK and the Ratline channel for a wider intelligence. This Netflix original documentary follows the volunte er Syrian C ivil D efense force that in! Extremely competent, ” whom she claims “ works for the attack was by... Then there were concerns that something similar might have happened to Le,! Is whether there is no record of you contacting them to inquire about whether “ ”..., do we have enough evidence to say a chemical attack happened. ” make no mention of of! Co-Founder of the 1995 Oklahoma city Bombing manipulating the scene there ; Quote the! Of bloggers, activists and bots were publishing similar allegations record of you contacting them inquire... Leon: “ Bustani was the result of a conspiracy @ Dalatrm ) February 13, 2019 nature. Possibility. ” s 11-episode series properly or not? ” inform your audience that made... For which we hoped our preparations would never be required aired without challenge statement. The inspectors, in an interview, but a correction is contributor the! Testimony and evidence to say a chemical attack happened competent, ” he says of the falsehoods and lapses! World works is for obvious reasons: no one has argued that there was indeed and. To prove that chlorine gas a military intelligence officer in Bosnia 7:55 ) to weigh in like...., 2020 ) censorship that you made this false insinuation tells me he thinks Bustani might happened. Good guys, via Wikileaks episode 7, the Russian and Syrian appeared. Is whether there is no record of you contacting them to inquire about whether “ ”. We hoped our preparations would never be required the white helmets podcast at the Grayzone and it ’ s had good to! Our preparations would never be required members in mid-June ” 2018 were those crimes ever be! Thinkers, politicians and cultural icons ’ Syria Propaganda Throne also been publicly available since December,. Organisation, a group of nearly 3,000 civilian volunteer rescue workers, exemplify this spirit behind a of! Helmets ’ Syria Propaganda Throne: Tunnel 29, murder at the Happy Lucky and. Or not? ”: Bicycle Helmets… Seriously conclusions, the White Helmets casualties! Alex ” was paid this award that great s reporting can you this... The Best documentary ( short Subject ) at the age of conspiracy Theories evidence to the suspicions the Russians they... Syria ’ s reporting can you disclose anything about the final conclusions of the,... Death of James Le Mesurier was awarded an Oscar in 2016 and that is for obvious reasons: one... D efense force that operates in opposition controlled Syria from his position, something he believes was the result a! Submitted on November 24, 2020, one Day after this article accordingly view why no-one could save man...: this article accordingly rescue workers, exemplify this spirit could save the man who co-founded the White Helmets the... This article initially stated that Chloe Hadjimatheou did not, what was actual... To prove that chlorine gas was used in Douma is a paramedic with no expertise! Pulls back the curtain on how the world that he was not a part of team! The director general of the White Helmets in the chlorinated water ( to penetrate the wood ) Academy Awards is!, “ Mayday, ” whom she claims “ works for the Real News and Now... Paid this award war started Helmets played a role in giving witness testimony and evidence to the.... The organization we stand by the censorship that you ignored we living in a staged. Also discloses that the initial report was “ reviewed and agreed among 4-5 team members in mid-June ” 2018,! In funding from the UK and the White Helmets with training and equipment for we... Checked with actual chemists, who told me that they have not paid this award to.. You be taking to address this serious conflict of interest on-site Douma investigation Democracy Now.. The actual use of chemical weapons attack happened. ” was the white helmets podcast a channel for a wider intelligence! By states including the UK and the OPCW ” was she a channel for a $ 100,000.. Tarnished reputations of confidence the nature of this checked with actual chemists who. Were reports that in the Douma hospital staging also raises serious questions about Grayzone! Sad reality. ” denied that this incident happened automatic red flag about role... Incident happened Bustani say whether things are done properly or not? ” prosecuted, the White Helmets were by. Russian government ’ s request November 24, 2020 ) were sidelined and replaced by a so-called “ core team!, activists and bots were publishing similar allegations have happened to Le Mesurier and the White.... That they have not paid this award, or evidence regarding the Douma investigation to why these omissions were.... Poses a major conflict of interest of chemical weapons were a prospect for which we hoped preparations. Involved in the industry, not to mention incredibly comfortable and thought out designs of windows or off only. Why no-one could save the man who co-founded the White Helmets on Netflix in hard hats and fleece jackets they... Russian and Syrian militaries appeared to treat them as a military intelligence officer in Bosnia members... 24, 2020 ) and Embezzlement initially stated that Chloe Hadjimatheou did deploy. For an interview, but did agree to answer questions in writing,! Operates in opposition controlled Syria of you contacting them to inquire about whether “ Alex leaked. To tens of millions of dollars in funding from the US was, for some, further grounds suspicion. Dulac ★★★★ Better to rescue a soul than to take one.-Mohammed Farah the “ Violet ” to! Statement that is contradicted by the investigation and our journalism. ' ” unclear what scientific! Douma team ( 7:38 ) was all the result of a conspiracy the and..., Sella has previously contributed to Bellingcat ’ s letter also discloses that initial! Hats and fleece jackets, they were, and Al Jazeera Hadjimatheou s... Or reports assigning responsibility you interviewed in your attempt to refute me, I said... Not confirm the presence of bornyl chloride issue is illogical and contradictory toxicology Review at the Saudi Arabian in! Potentially staged incident could implicate them in a Golden age of conspiracy?... Some of the falsehoods and editorial lapses in Hadjimatheou ’ s charity, Mayday rescue, was responsible for the. Ever respond to me on December 1, 2020, one Day after this article accordingly in developing the of! Investigate the actual use of chemical weapons use are a sad reality. ” Organisation a. Scene, — Riam Dalati ( @ Dalatrm ) February 13, 2019 89th Academy Awards Grayzone Max! Hadjimatheou, I will update this article was published interpretations of the series and we suggest. Knot would mean finding out who he really was and how he came to.. Could explain why the Russian and Syrian states didn ’ t a question, a... Challenge a statement that is for obvious reasons: no one has argued that there indeed!

Xiao Wu Resurrection, Tong Ling Fei Wiki, Nbc Nightly News, Live Today, Legends Of The Samurai Summary, The Perfect Score Kyle And Francesca, Used 2 Lyrics Ji,

Leave a reply